image
author Image

Cloud vs Local Smart Plugs in Australia: Which is Better for Your Home?

Smart plugs are becoming an increasingly popular way for Australian households to make their homes more automated and energy efficient. These handy little devices allow you to control lamps, appliances, and other electronics remotely via a smartphone app or through voice commands.

But should you choose a cloud-based smart plug that relies on an internet connection, or a local smart plug that operates entirely on your home Wi-Fi network? There are pros and cons to both options. In this article, we’ll compare cloud and local smart plugs so you can decide which is better suited for your smart home needs.

How Do Smart Plugs Work?

Before diving into the nitty gritty differences between cloud and local smart plugs, let’s first understand exactly what smart plugs are and how they work.

A smart plug is a device that you plug into a regular electrical outlet. You then plug a lamp, appliance, or other electronic device into the smart plug. The smart plug connects to your home Wi-Fi network and allows you to control the connected device remotely from your smartphone or through voice commands.

For example, you could plug a floor lamp into a smart plug and then turn that lamp on or off from your phone, even when you’re away from home. You can also set schedules to automatically turn the lamp on at certain times of day. Smart plugs essentially add wireless connectivity and remote control to “dumb” appliances and electronics.

Cloud vs Local: Key Differences

The main difference between cloud and local smart plugs comes down to how they communicate and where your data is stored:

Cloud-based smart plugs connect to servers on the internet (the cloud) to relay commands and data between your smartphone and the plug. This allows you to control your devices from anywhere as long as you have an internet connection. However, it also means some of your data is stored on the manufacturer’s servers.

Local smart plugs do not need an internet connection. Instead, they communicate directly with your home Wi-Fi router and smartphone app on your local network. This means no data leaves your home. However, it limits remote access to times when you are connected to your home Wi-Fi.

Below we’ll explore these two options in more detail so you can determine which type of smart plug is the best choice for your needs and preferences.

Benefits of Cloud-Based Smart Plugs

Cloud-connected smart plugs offer some advantages that make them appealing, especially for people who want seamless remote access to their devices. Here are some of the key benefits of choosing a cloud-based smart plug model:

Remote Access from Anywhere

One of the biggest perks of cloud-based smart plugs is the ability to control your devices from anywhere in the world as long as you have an internet connection. For example, if you’re on holiday overseas you can still switch your lamp on and off or turn on your coffee maker back home. This remote access can provide both convenience and peace of mind.

Voice Control Integration

Most cloud-based smart plugs have compatibility with voice assistants like Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant. This allows you to control your smart plugs with handy voice commands. Just say “Alexa, turn on the living room lamp” and your cloud-connected smart plug will spring into action.

Automation and Scheduling

Cloud smart plugs often come with automation features through their accompanying app. This allows you to set schedules, so your devices turn on or off automatically at set times each day or night. You can also set up triggers like “when I arrive home” or “when the sun sets” to activate your smart plugs.

Third-Party App Integration

In addition to automation through the manufacturer’s app, many cloud-based smart plugs integrate with third-party smart home platforms like IFTTT and Zapier. This allows even more complex automations by connecting your smart plugs with hundreds of other internet-based services and devices.

Software Updates and New Features

Because they rely on the manufacturer’s cloud servers, internet-connected smart plugs can be continually updated with new software and capabilities. The company can push bug fixes, security patches, and new features to your smart plug over the air. With a local smart plug, updating firmware may require a manual process.

So in summary, cloud-based smart plugs make an enticing option if remote access, expansive automation, and voice control are your top priorities. Just keep in mind that these conveniences come with some downsides as well.

Drawbacks of Cloud-Based Smart Plugs

While they offer neat features, cloud-connected smart plugs also come with some disadvantages to consider:

Requires a Reliable Internet Connection

Cloud-based smart plugs rely on having a solid internet connection at all times. If your home internet goes down, you’ll lose the ability to control your devices remotely until it starts working again. This can be frustrating if you frequently experience internet outages.

Potential Privacy and Security Issues

With your usage data stored on the manufacturer’s cloud servers, privacy and security risks are a concern. Servers could be vulnerable to hackers, and companies could potentially use your data for advertising or other purposes without your permission.

Ongoing Subscription Fees

Some brands of cloud smart plugs require an ongoing monthly or annual subscription for full functionality. So the initial purchase price might not be the only cost associated with the device. Always check whether recurring fees apply.

Dependent on Company Staying in Business

If the company that makes your cloud smart plugs goes out of business, the devices may stop working properly. They rely on the company’s servers to operate, so no company means no more support.

So while cloud smart plugs provide some cool capabilities, the trade-off is reliance on the internet and third-party companies. Next let’s look at how local smart plugs measure up.

Benefits of Local Smart Plugs

Local smart plugs that connect only to your home Wi-Fi network have their own set of advantages as well. Here are some of the best reasons to choose a smart plug that works locally without an internet connection:

No Need for Internet Connectivity

Once set up, local smart plugs do not require an active internet connection to function. As long as they are connected to your home Wi-Fi router, you can control them directly from your smartphone on the same network. This means power outages or internet disruptions won’t affect your ability to use the smart plugs when you’re home.

Enhanced Privacy and Security

With a local smart plug, your usage data remains inside your home network and is not transmitted over the internet. This prevents your data from being exposed by potential security breaches. Local smart plugs provide privacy and security without you having to worry about how the manufacturer handles or secures data in the cloud.

No Ongoing Fees

Local smart plugs do not rely on a manufacturer’s cloud infrastructure, so they do not require any monthly or annual subscription fees for full functionality. The only cost is the initial purchase price of the smart plug hardware.

Continue Working Without Support

Even if the company stops providing support or goes out of business entirely, your local smart plugs should continue operating normally for years. Because they don’t depend on cloud servers or services, local smart plugs aren’t bound to the fate of a manufacturer.

Control When Away with a VPN

Though local smart plugs prioritise direct access on your home network, you can set up remote access from anywhere by using a virtual private network (VPN). The VPN allows you securely tunnel into your home network as if you were there. This provides remote functionality while maintaining privacy.

If you want smart home devices without relying on the internet, a local smart plug is a wise choice. Nonetheless, local models aren’t perfect either…

Drawbacks of Local Smart Plugs

Here are a few potential downsides to keep in mind with local smart plugs:

No Remote Access Without VPN

Unless you set up a VPN, you can only directly control your local smart plugs when connected to your home Wi-Fi. This means no turning lights on and off from the office or your hotel room overseas like you could with a cloud-based plug.

Limited Voice Control Support

Since most virtual assistants like Alexa connect through the cloud, compatibility with local smart plugs is limited. Some local models may not work with voice commands at all. Check compatibility before purchasing if voice control is important to you.

Minimal Third-Party Integrations

Without cloud connectivity, options for integrating local smart plugs with other smart devices and web services are scarce. You’ll likely be limited to the features of the plug manufacturer’s app. If you want expansive smart home functionality, local models may fall short.

Manual Firmware Updates

Updating your local smart plugs with new firmware requires manually downloading and installing the update on each device. Cloud-based models receive convenient automatic updates pushed from the company’s servers.

So local smart plugs prioritise privacy and control at the cost of some smart home conveniences. But which option is best for the average Australian household?

Which is Better for Most Aussie Homes?

When comparing the pros and cons, local smart plugs often provide the better balance for many Australian homes. Here’s why:

  • You don’t have to worry about internet outages disrupting your ability to control smart plugs when you’re home. With Australia’s vast spaces between cities, internet reliability can be hit and miss.
  • Data privacy is a major plus. Most Aussies don’t feel comfortable having details about their home appliance usage stored on a company’s servers overseas. Local models keep all data in your control.
  • No ongoing fees align with Australia’s preference for lower-cost options when available. Local smart plugs don’t nickle-and-dime you with subscriptions.
  • Remote access when away is still possible through a VPN if you set it up. Even local models can provide some conveniences without the privacy trade-off.

However, if seamless voice control and extensive automation are your top priorities, the connectivity and integrations of cloud-based smart plugs may better suit your needs. Consider how you plan to use and configure your smart home system when choosing between cloud vs local models.

And of course, you can always mix and match – choose local plugs for devices where privacy is more important, while utilizing cloud plugs for appliances where remote access is more valuable. With the right balance, you can maximize both convenience and control with your smart home.

Now that we’ve compared the pros and cons of cloud vs local smart plugs, let’s look at some of the best local models available in Australia. These recommended smart plugs keep your data secure while providing convenient control of lights, household appliances, electronics and more:

  • Control 3 devices independently from your smartphone
  • Compact all-in-one design with 3 smart outlets and 3 USB ports
  • No hub required – connects directly to Wi-Fi
  • Scheduled on/off times can be set for each outlet

Belkin WeMo Smart Plug

  • Only requires a Wi-Fi connection, no separate hub needed
  • Control your devices from anywhere in your home
  • Sets schedules to turn lights and appliances on or off automatically
  • Compatible with Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa

Lenovo Smart Plug

  • Directly connects to home Wi-Fi without a hub
  • Control and schedule through the Lenovo Link app
  • Energy monitoring shows power usage over time
  • Compact low-profile design maximizes outlet space

11 Function Smart Switchboard by Ecoline

  • 11 AC power outlets that can be controlled individually
  • Program on/off times for each outlet
  • App and voice control through Google Assistant
  • Monitor energy usage for the full switchboard or individual outlets

This covers a few excellent local smart plug options available from Australian electrical retailers. Just remember to always employ a licensed electrician to install any new electrical devices in your home.

Let the Experts Install Your Smart Plugs

While smart plugs themselves simply plug into ordinary outlets, it’s highly advisable to have your new smart home devices installed by qualified electrical professionals. Here are some key reasons why:

  • Electrical safety – Mistakes in working with mains AC power can result in serious electrocution hazards. Leave electrical installations to experienced electricians.
  • Up to code – Electricians ensure your smart home setup meets Australian electrical standards and regulations for legal compliance and safety.
  • Maximizing compatibility – Electricians have experience with making smart home devices from various brands work together smoothly.
  • Professional experience – Electrical contractors have the right tools and knowledge to install smart plugs properly in the optimal locations.
  • Warranties – Having an electrician install your smart plugs and switches preserves the manufacturer warranties. DIY installation often voids warranties.

While smart plugs make the process of adding automation to your home more accessible, don’t let DIY enthusiasm put your safety at risk. Partnering with a professional electrician gives you peace of mind while setting up the smart home you’ve always wanted.

Let Your Home Get Smarter

Adding smart plugs is an easy way to get started with home automation. Choosing local plug models means you can enjoy the convenience of app and voice-controlled devices without worrying about security, reliability, or ongoing costs. Just be sure to have your new smart plugs installed properly by a certified electrician.

Resources
What are the security and privacy risks of using smart plugs in your home? Smart plugs, like any other internet-connected device, can be vulnerable to cyberattacks. Hackers can exploit flaws in the smart plug’s firmware, software, or cloud infrastructure.
Before You Buy A Smart Plug, Read The Privacy and Software Update Policy Smart plugs may collect data about energy usage that could potentially be used for advertising or compromised in a security breach.
One smart plug isn’t so bright when it comes to security A security firm found a smart socket vulnerable to hacks due to weak factory passwords and unencrypted traffic.
Hackers can use smart plugs to break into your home network Cheap smart plugs could be exploited by criminals to gain access to other devices on the network.
Recommendations on local (non-cloud) Australian Smart Plugs? Reddit discussion on finding local smart plug models in Australia that don’t require cloud connectivity.
Belkin’s Wemo Smart Plug Mini V2 has a security issue Security researchers discovered an exploitable vulnerability in the Wemo Smart Plug Mini V2.